- Details
-
Latest
-
Monday, 13 February 2012 02:30
-
By caribarena news
Antigua St John's - Before the Chinese Power Plant press conference, Caribarena had conducted an investigation to try and understand exactly how the power plant contract was carried out.
As our returning readers probably know, several Chinese companies, including Shanxi Diesel Engine Heavy Industry Co Ltd (SXD), Xi’an Marine Equipment Engineering Research Academy (XMEA), and the Beijing Construction Engineering Group (BCEG), were involved in the procurement, manufacturing, shipping, and construction processes.
The plates on the side of the engines indicate that SXD is the manufacturer of the engines.
The plates on the front of the engines indicate that XMEA is the manufacturer of the engines. Both companies claim to have signed contracts with BCEG for the Antigua Power Plant project.
Neither company was present at the government’s much-hyped press conference. And to add to the mix, Caribarena is yet to receive answers to any of the questions sent to the government following the press conference.
Clearly, the situation is quite confusing. To make things simple, Caribarena took the liberty of preparing the following diagram. This should make the interaction between the various parties easier to understand.

One critical question that Caribarena raised in a previous article, which went largely unnoticed, is why did both XMEA and SXD sign a contract with BCEG?
SXD manufactures engines under its license from MAN Diesel and Turbo SE in Germany. SXD is also a shareholder of XMEA, a company that is partly owned by a myriad of other Chinese companies.
As such, it would be understandable if XMEA had permission to act as an agent on behalf of SXD.
However,
SXD claims on its website to have signed a contract with BCEG for the Antigua Power Plant Project, while
XMEA also claims to have signed an “equipment procurement” contract with BCEG. Both contracts were signed in 2008.
An article on XMEA’s website entails the contents of the contract signed with XMEA to include “6x5 MW HFO G-sets and their auxiliary systems”. But if a contract was signed between SXD (as the original manufacturer of the engines) and BCEG, why was XMEA necessary?
So who really provided the engines, XMEA or SXD? Who did BCEG really sign contract for the generator sets and their auxiliary systems?
Another interesting fact is the involvement of MAN Diesel and Turbo SE Germany in all of this. On MAN Diesel and Turbo’s website is an article titled “Genset Delivery Sparks Chinese Celebration”.
In this article, various representatives of SXD and Man Diesel and Turbo China gathered to celebrate the delivery of two 12v32/40 gensets. These generator sets are identical to the ones delivered to Antigua & Barbuda. And yet, of the Antigua & Barbuda project, where six engines were delivered, no mention, press release, or article was published.
Caribarena has asked MAN Diesel and Turbo SE Germany about this and other matters, but MAN has not yet responded to these questions.
Meanwhile, Ambassador Shoul and the PM are solving all of their problems by accusing the media and the opposition of being “libelous” and “unpatriotic”.
So to the PM, if being unpatriotic means turning a blind eye to government projects and assuming everything is fine and dandy, then Caribarena is probably very unpatriotic. And also, Caribarena’s efforts to locate the photos of the power plant previously on the government website have been unsuccessful.
See related stories:
Govt Promises Chinese Power Plant Answers
Another Unsettling Discovery at Power Plant
Bird To Seek Outside Advice on Power Plant
MP Joseph Accuses Government of Breaking Laws
Antigua Power Plant - No Straight Answers
Chinese Power Plant or Antigua's White Elephant
Power Plant Production Costs Explained
PM Says ALP Distorted Power Plant Info
No Plan Behind the Power Plant
Yearwood Presents Figures on Chinese Power Plant
23 Comments In This Article
Pics are there
Nemo
Pics are there
Nemo
@ Colin - Design Build or P3 Contracts?
John French II
Hooray for Avid Reader
Anybody else want to follow - and what's all this talk I hear about some people being "unpatriotic" and others "defaming our generous friends the Chinese"?
Anyway: maybe "Avid Reader" is becoming an "Avid Thinker!"
There's this popular local saying (Antiguans & Barbudans love sayings) about "force" making water "go uphill" ...
Colin
@ All Antiguans who like sillyness
Nobody can cry foul, the governmnet should have a warranty on this, so that the company has a responsiblity to send someone back to Antigua to inspect and fix or replace.
Where is the warranty?, that is what all of you on here should be asking the government to show you. If you determine that the plant is not what YOU KNOW the country paid for, then you can insist that the government do its job.
Avid Reader
GET REAL ,CANT FOOL ME
MERCHANT
to anu268
I've been back and forth on Caribarena for a little while now. They aren't that stupid. Why would they say the pictures weren't there if the pictures were? It would be too easy to hammer them. Besides, I looked for the pictures myself this morning, when I read this whole story, and I couldn't find them either. So send my regards to your supervisor, and thank him for returning the photos for us to see.
listen dont hear
@John2
anu268
Wrong registration Number?
Mindful
@anu268
John2
Great job Caribarena
jeb
misinformation
anu268
Caribarena please!!!
BCEG got the intial contract and they have a right if necessary to sub-contract out since it would give value to their client. BCEG is a large company that has been around for years, so before Caribarena give a black eye, look at what the government of A&B did incorrectly. It appears as if they are the culprits in this problem.
Does the person at Caribarena who is pushing this angle of this issue believes that only one company is responsible for the production of the automobile he/she drives. Totally Silly.
Avid Reader
jp farnsworth
Antiguan Woman
When is it enough
JP Farnsworth
Re-interestedD
Donna Cha
Cool ruler( the upholder is worse than the theif)
ANTIGUAN WOMAN
Good work Caribarena..
Martin.L
RE: Power Plant Companies Relationship Explained
Cool Ruler
good job
goed man
loosing face
JP Farnsworth
Much ado about nothing
InteresteD
had your chance
carvaa
RSS