- Details
-
Latest
-
Saturday, 24 March 2012 02:30
-
By caribarena news
Antigua St John's - APUA Chairman Clarvis Joseph's announcement that the company will disconnect an entire household for one outstanding utility has sparked far-reaching criticism from the community and the opposition political party.
ALP politician Molwyn Joseph told Caribarena.com that the matter could be discussed at the party’s executive meeting on Friday.
He said he could not say with certainty that the move was illegal, but said he suspects it is.
Joseph said on Wednesday, “We’re going to discontinue services… If you owe me for water, you’re owing me for electricity.”
The move, which took immediate effect, reportedly aims to collect the EC$682 M owed to APUA. The government is said to owe $330 M, while statutory corporations owe about $19 M, and private businesses owe an estimated $50 M.
The MP believes the legality of the issue is secondary considering the moral and ethical angles that must be taken into account.
“Government has stated repeatedly that its failure to perform is directly linked to the global recession," Joseph said, "and the same government does not seem to recognise that the people are also suffering because of the recession in terms of their ability to meet their demand because of the heavy taxes put in place in recent years."
He added that Antigua & Barbuda has gone through three consecutive years of negative growth, which has affected jobs and livelihood, with even Social Security falling short in intake.
“If government is making that case, then the same government should give recognition to the fact that the people have equal or more severe difficulty in meeting their demand for same reasons,” the ALP MP said.
He labelled the move as “Draconian,” “heartless,” and “extremely insensitive,” noting that the Authority and the government are taking the option from the people to honour essential bills while still being able to feed themselves.
"This is an extremely vexing issue because it is creating more hardship for the people… I do not believe it is a sensible policy for government to disconnect the service of water because someone is delinquent on his or her electricity bill,” Joseph said.
Examining the issue from a management perspective, the former government minister said he does not see the logic in the decision that failure to pay one bill will deny other services because the people simply will not pay a bill for a service they no longer receive – especially if their other services are paid up.
He suggested that the company would have been better served to encourage people who actually pay some of their bills to continue doing so.
"From a management point of view, I don't think this measure would improve this situation at all," Joseph said. "It is as foolish from a management point of view as it is from a humane one. I frown upon this decision. APUA will find it is not one that would be eagerly embraced by the people of Antigua & Barbuda.”
Update:
Coming out of the ALP Executive Meeting on Friday night, opposition leader Lester Bird had committed to meeting with Prime Minister Spencer and proposing that the new APUA policy be withdrawn.
The party had also agreed that should that approach fail, it will protest it publicly.
63 Comments In This Article
Just one question for Mr Jarvis
Mr Jarvis can you tell us what was APUA's debt just before you became chairman in 2006?
And I also heard Mr Jarvis say on radio "if you don't pay me" and "when you owe me." So I guess it's fair to say that he believes APUA is his and not the people of Antigua & Barbuda's ... maybe that explains why nobody can see "his accounts" for "his APUA" !!!
The Wadadli Blogger
@Mahela-your comment is quite foolish.
ANTIGUAN WOMAN
@Slythatguy
ANTIGUAN WOMAN
claification & SlythatGuy
..
tenman
@ Tenman
SlyThatGuy
Elder state's woman
Jane
what we deserve
dirt
young analyst
..
tenman
Some figures are missing
Total Owed EC$682M-EC399M= EC$283 who owes this amount?
Gov owe EC$330M+
Stat owe EC$19M+
Pri Busi owe EC50M+
________
EC$399M
I guess his statement is unfinished, looking forward to hear who owes this amount!!!!
young analyst
what?
Mavis
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
john d
Mahela
nevil
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
Mahela
SlyThatGuy - get real
..
tenman
Remember Cable & Wireless
Call de elections now!!!!!!!
TimeWillTell
@ Antiguan Woman
SlyThatGuy
APUA IS A GOVT TORTURE TOOL
galileo
so sorry
purcell
Who Clarvis Joseph think he is?
Justice
@SLYTHATGUY
ANTIGUAN WOMAN
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
SlyThatGuy
APUA's audited financial statements
Quote:..
tenman
HC
..
tenman
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
HC
@GET IT
ANTIGUAN WOMAN
TIME FOR THE UPP TO GO.
ANTIGUAN WOMAN
Perplexed
..
tenman
MP Slams New APUA Policy
SlyThatGuy
C. Joseph has to pay for Bancorp!
Oh and he needs More revenu to buy spare parts from his xxxxx xxxx /xxxxt !
Yankee
@TENMAN
Perplexed
Rate too high
nevil
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
UNITED STATES
some suggestions part 2 of 2
9. Time to follow though on having sales staff motivated with commissions selling APUA products
10. Time for APUA's information systems applications to be updated, so that the mostly manual data management process will end: One aspect of this would be to allow customers to pay their bills online. Another would be to provide an automated service where customers can check their bill online and via phone.
..
tenman
some suggestions part 1 of 2
1. Work our a policy with employees eg(in Billing and Control) that they will be given a percentage based on how many of the long standing AR they are able to collect.
.2 Introduce a policy where delinquent customers who are unable to pay, will get access to a prepaid type service, similar to what exists in DR
3. Improve your credit control systems to ensure there is no repeat of this mess
4. Extend the discount offered to customers who pay their electricity early, also to customers who pay their telephone early.
5. Ensure that the staff who deal with credit control and properly trained and equipped to do their jobs.
6. Present financial reports to the general public who its claimed have shares in APUA, so that they can start to feel as if they really own this entity.
7. The effect of doing the above may help APUA in controlling waste, where customers/owner s will report attempts to rob APUA
..
tenman
MaeStro - fire the management
My added question is how could a company allow 2.17 years (they make around 26 million in revenue monthly) of its revenue to be in the accounts receivable category? This gives the company a accounts receivable turnover (ART) which is less than 1. I decided to take a quick look at Saint Lucia and see what obtains there. For 2010 their (LUCELEC) AR was $59,782,912 while revenue was $276,270,465 which gives them a ART of almost 5 . The high AR figure from APUA is bloated and indicates much of this figure will need to be written off. Apua's ART being less than 1 and the situation is not mirrored in the region, clearly indicates that this company's management is inefficient.
..
tenman
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
This administration has decimated the poor and middle cl** with excessive taxes. Where do they expect people to get money from? Most people in A&B have to juggle the payment of their bills these days - thanks to the UPP. These guys need to wake up and smell the bush tea.
DadliMan
The Kings Palace
On another note while on building readiness the other King of Revenue reform said Inland Revenue would have been in thir palace at Woods by mid December 2011 we are at the end of March 2012 and no movement Hmmmm.
MaeStro
List incomplete plus what is the PLAN?
Another important bit of detail King Chaiman for to inform his peasants about is exactly how is his ILL-conceived plan is expected to work. Is it when a disconnection notice is generated for say water they will ask the electricity crew to go along with them? And how are they going to accurately identify the phone for the said client given people with the same name live in the same village?
Or is the anger and hostility I hear from King Chairman really directed at the business community for which all services are easily identifiable?
MaeStro
Clue me in pt2
APUA has 682m on the street ...
Government alone - the chief abuser of APUA - owes 33om ...
The amounts owed by Statutory corporations and businesses combined (a mere 69m) - if paid in full immediately - would barely dent the total outstanding ...
APUA conducts regular disconnection programs to minimise delinquency ...
So ... you mean to tell me that APUA will continue to give a free ride to the chief abuser ... and put the hammer on households?
Colin
Reaction needed.
jeb
The Abuse of APUA
These people never bring their bills up to date and they are usually the ones with money. The politicians in Antigua are currently the cause of what is wrong with APUA, Molwyn Joseph needs to address these problems.
Avid Reader
power to the people
Can you imagine what APUA can do if we the people decide no more?
Can you imagine if we all decided we are not paying at all . we are marching in front of APUA until not only the government kick this ridiculous decision but until government lower all utilities prices?
Can u imagine?
I guess u can't.
Pity we can't unit for ourselves.
Get it
Stop giving free utilities to the selected elite!
Morris
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
It looks like you have taken a page from Inland Revenue. The ones who have been paying all along, are the easy targets to squeeze even more out of, while the big guys who have paid NOTHING, continue to pay nothing. That's right Clarvis, make some poor senior citizen sit in darkness because she ran short on the water bill, while the Ministry of Finance keeps the A/C cold enough you could store meat products in the hallways.
HTH Peppersauce
@ tenman
From what is revealed in this article, the gov't owes more than 51% ($330M + $19M) of the debt and claims global recession as an excuse for not paying and get away with it. However, the struggling citizens who are more severely impacted by the said global recession are not given any sympathy.
Morris
APUA - Breach Of Contract?
Quote: "L'etat Cest Moi!" "Apres Moi Le Deluge!" He is Now APUA! APUA Is Now He!
Quote: What Hogwash? It can be argued that there are more than one Contract. APUA Structure, Systems and Processes make this clear. The application documents which constitute the Contract leave no doubt.
Any Legal Beagles Here? Heaven Help The Nation Of Antigua & Barbuda.
John French II
De Real Observer
Osbert R. Frederick
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
my way of helping
arrogance
nevil
People First or Last?
Poor Issy
Sen me a Pan wid Flambo
As for cutting services, start with your your biggest debtors and then work your way down to your smallest. That's if you have the law on your side.
Cash flow problems?? Cut your losses and get rid of that gray and blue elephant on the corner of High and East streets.
Barry
RE: MP Slams New APUA Policy
I guess its time again to Gird your loins and light your candles.
H.N.I.C.
Mr Joseph
Mr Sabruski
Joseph v Joseph
in Antigua that is not the case, each service has a separate bill, this has given customer customers the discretion to choose the bill more important to them to pay. The question is, does the APUA act gives the board the power to implement this? It may be a good thing if they start combining all the services on one bill like is done in NY
Cool Ruler
really APUA??????????
chuupsssssssssss
Is this legal?
The first person with money that this policy affect will take them to court and I am certain they will win. I apply to APUA for telephone service you cannot bundle all the other services simply because you are the supplier that is both ridiculous and asinine and crazy. Who is the legal advisor for APUA? Did Joseph seek legal advice on this before going public? Was this an IMF suggestion?
MaeStro
i hate this
purcell
time for him to go
winston
time for him to go
winston
strange turn
APUA plays a dangerous game when they disconnect essential services like Water or electricity for a over due telephone bill. They are a monopoly and therefore should not have powers to do such. In addition the format of the telephone bill provides no transparency (numbers called are not listed). Its is time Antigua had a separate utilities authority to oversee companies like APUA.
..
tenman
All or nothing
JW
Disconnect Joseph
JP Farnsworth
What a irresposible Statement
“We’re going to discontinue services… If you owe me for water, you’re owing me for electricity.” Not if you owe APUA, Not if you owe
the Authority. But if you owe ME.
Each utility required a separate contract. The services were never sold as a bundle, yet one man, who OWNS APUA, now decides HE will bundle all utilities. In any developed country that statement would be is sad legacy. He has embar**ed himself and the government.
While we are at it, here's a question to ponder. Isn't it a very poor reflection on ANY govt when one govt agency has to cut a service from another govt agency such as was the case with Port & APUA?
Nine
RSS